Manic Street Preachers – Importance of Critical Thinking
‘Decline and Fall’, showcasing their expertise in galactic heartland rock with thunderous energy and chiming pianos; Critical Thinking delivers plenty of robust and energetic rock anthems. However, the album truly shines when the band ventures into new territory. Tracks like ‘People Ruin Paintings’ exude a lively energy and feature a slightly unconventional structure, while ‘Late Day Peaks’ introduces a surprising Japanese city pop vibe, showcasing a refreshing departure from their usual style.
Despite the album’s strong musical composition, there are moments where the lyrical content falls short. The opening track, ‘Critical Thinking’, presents an icy new wave sound reminiscent of bands like Kick-era INXS or The Blue Aeroplanes. However, lines referencing “free ports”, “smart meters”, and “skyscrapers of untruth” veer into confusing territory, causing a slight disconnect from the overall message. Similarly, ‘One Man Militia’, inspired by Queen Elizabeth II’s funeral, delves into themes of “rigid dogma” that may not seamlessly fit within the rock genre.
The album truly shines when exploring personal narratives rather than grand societal themes. ‘Dear Stephen’, a track recounting Morrissey’s gesture of sending a ‘Get well soon’ postcard to a young Nicky Wire, resonates more authentically than songs focusing on abstract concepts. The Manic Street Preachers excel when delving into the specifics of real-life experiences, proving that subtlety and nuance can have a more profound impact than overt political statements. Following Anton Chekhov’s advice to “show, don’t tell”, the band’s ability to depict individual stories with depth and emotion resonates more powerfully than bold declarations.
Despite a few lyrical missteps, Critical Thinking remains a compelling album filled with captivating songs. The Manic Street Preachers continue to deliver their signature style, blending catchy hooks and anthemic melodies that resonate with their dedicated fanbase. With a nod to their roots and a willingness to experiment with new sounds, the band proves that even after nearly four decades, they can still produce music that captivates audiences and prompts introspection. In essence, Critical Thinking serves as a powerful State of the Nation address, inviting listeners to tune in, reflect, and engage with the band’s enduring musical legacy.