Outlaw Musical Hits the Mark at New York Stage Review

Dead Outlaw, a riveting and intense musical, tells the story of Elmer McCurdy, a real-life outlaw who met a tragic and bizarre fate. This daring production, with a score by David Yazbek and Erik Della Penna, captivates audiences with its unconventional narrative and eclectic musical compositions.

The musical opens with McCurdy atop a train in the plains of Oklahoma, setting the tone for the dark and macabre tale that unfolds. The transition from a gentle ballad to a brash and gritty country-rock number sets the stage for the audacious journey ahead. As the story progresses, it delves into McCurdy’s life of crime and the events that led to his untimely demise at the hands of law enforcement.

What sets Dead Outlaw apart is its unique premise, inspired by the true story of Elmer McCurdy. Following his death, McCurdy’s body was embalmed and put on display as a sideshow attraction, traveling across the country for decades. The unexpected discovery of his remains during a TV shoot in 1976 unveils the grim reality of his posthumous journey.

David Yazbek, known for his innovative and diverse musical compositions, brings his signature flair to Dead Outlaw. His collaboration with rock songwriter Erik Della Penna results in a dynamic and compelling score that captures the essence of McCurdy’s tumultuous life. From poignant ballads to high-octane rock numbers, Yazbek showcases his versatility and creativity throughout the production.

The cast of Dead Outlaw delivers stellar performances, with Andrew Durand leading the ensemble as the enigmatic titular character. Durand’s portrayal of McCurdy exudes a captivating blend of ferocity and vulnerability, keeping the audience captivated from start to finish. Jeb Brown’s multifaceted roles add depth and humor to the narrative, while the rest of the cast shines in their respective characters.

Director David Cromer’s vision brings Dead Outlaw to life with keen insight and creativity. The production, which originally gained acclaim off-Broadway, seamlessly transitions to the Broadway stage, maintaining its raw energy and intensity. Arnulfo Maldonado’s striking set design, centered around a cube-like bandstand, creates a visually compelling backdrop for the unfolding drama.

As the narrative unfolds, Dead Outlaw explores themes of fame, mortality, and the darker aspects of human nature. Through its eclectic score and captivating performances, the musical invites audiences to delve into the complexities of McCurdy’s life and legacy. With a blend of dark humor, poignant moments, and explosive musical numbers, Dead Outlaw offers a unique and unforgettable theatrical experience.

In conclusion, Dead Outlaw stands out as a riveting and original musical that pushes the boundaries of traditional storytelling. With its compelling narrative, exceptional performances, and innovative score, the production captivates audiences and leaves a lasting impression. Dead Outlaw is a must-see for theater enthusiasts looking for a bold and unforgettable theatrical experience.