Review of Car Seat Headrest’s album “The Scholars”
Car Seat Headrest has made a triumphant return with their latest album, “The Scholars,” after a five-year hiatus. Led by the talented Will Toledo, the band has evolved from a solo project into a full-fledged band that continues to push boundaries and challenge expectations with their music.
Following their previous album, “Making a Door Less Open,” which received mixed reviews, “The Scholars” marks a daring departure for the band. While some critics were not entirely impressed with their previous work, Toledo and his bandmates have crafted an album that stands out for its uniqueness and boldness.
The album is set in a fictional university called Parnassus, with a central focus on a goat character named Beolco who believes he is the reincarnation of a lost playwright called “The Scop.” This fantastical setting adds a new dimension to Toledo’s already captivating storytelling, making “The Scholars” a truly immersive experience.
Despite its imaginative concept, the album still explores familiar themes of yearning, existentialism, identity, and self-discovery. Tracks like “Lady Gay Approximately” and “Deveraux” delve into complex issues such as acceptance, transformation, and familial expectations, offering a fresh perspective on these timeless themes.
Musically, Car Seat Headrest retains their signature indie rock sound, with tracks like “CCF (I’m Gonna Stay with you)” showcasing their knack for crafting infectious melodies and captivating instrumentals. While the album may not feature the explosive climaxes that defined their earlier works, it introduces a new texture and depth to their music that is both refreshing and compelling.
The heart of the album lies in the central suite of songs, including “Gethsemane,” “Reality,” and the epic 19-minute track “Planet Desperation.” These songs showcase the band’s versatility and creativity, with guitarist Ethan Ives delivering standout performances that add layers of complexity and emotion to the music.
As the album progresses, Car Seat Headrest takes listeners on a journey through a range of emotions and experiences, culminating in the upbeat and infectious track “True/False Lover,” which serves as a fitting conclusion to this musical odyssey.
Overall, “The Scholars” is a testament to Car Seat Headrest’s willingness to take risks and explore new territories in their music. With its innovative concept, compelling storytelling, and dynamic musical arrangements, the album solidifies the band’s reputation as one of the most exciting and innovative acts in indie rock today.