Bob Dylan and members of The Beatles disliked Neil Young’s music – Far Out Magazine
In the world of art, subjectivity reigns supreme. What one person considers a masterpiece, another may view as trash. This sentiment holds true for music as well, with differing opinions on what constitutes good or bad art. Neil Young, a legendary figure in the music industry, has faced both adoration and criticism throughout his illustrious career.
Over his five-decade-long career, Neil Young has managed to carve out a unique space for himself in the rock world. His ability to stay relevant and continue headlining major festivals like Glastonbury in 2025 is a testament to his artistry and authenticity. Young’s dedication to creating deliberate, artistic, and genuine music sets him apart from his peers.
While authenticity is a cornerstone of the music industry, few artists embody it as effortlessly as Neil Young. His commitment to staying true to his artistry and refusing to conform to mainstream trends has earned him a loyal following. Despite his success, Young has not been immune to criticism, even from his fellow music icons.
Bob Dylan, John Lennon, and George Harrison, all legendary figures in their own right, have expressed their dislike for Neil Young’s music. Bob Dylan felt that Young was imitating his style in songs like “Heart of Gold,” which led to tension between the two artists. John Lennon, on the other hand, took issue with the lyrics of Young’s song “My, My, Hey, Hey,” particularly the line “It’s better to burn out than to fade away.” Lennon’s perspective shifted after the birth of his son Sean, prompting him to reevaluate his views on self-destruction in music.
George Harrison, known for his candid nature, did not mince words when expressing his disdain for Neil Young’s music. Harrison openly confessed that he was not a fan of Young’s work, criticizing both his guitar playing and singing voice. Unlike Dylan and Lennon, who were more open to appreciating other aspects of Young’s music, Harrison’s animosity towards Young seemed unwavering.
Despite facing criticism from some of music’s biggest icons, Neil Young remains a revered figure in the industry. His ability to create music that resonates with audiences across generations is a testament to his enduring talent. While not everyone may appreciate his style, Young’s authenticity and dedication to his craft continue to inspire fans and fellow musicians alike. In the end, criticism, even from legendary figures like Bob Dylan, John Lennon, and George Harrison, is simply part of the journey for an artist like Neil Young.