Issue with BBC Music’s 1984 albums list identified by AudioPhix
BBC Music is known for its lists, and while they produce some good ones, there always seems to be a flaw. This is the nature of ranking music – it is impossible to please everyone. However, it is still important to point out mistakes when they occur.
In a recent list ranking the best albums of 1984, BBC Music made some solid choices. Prince’s Purple Rain soundtrack at the top and Depeche Mode’s Some Great Reward at No. 14 both feel right and fitting. However, one glaring omission from the list was U2’s The Unforgettable Fire.
During this time, U2 was in the midst of producing a series of remarkable albums, with The Unforgettable Fire sandwiched between War and The Joshua Tree. This could arguably be one of the greatest three-album runs in music history. Despite only releasing one album in 1984, U2’s decision to go against the grain was evident in The Unforgettable Fire.
In a music industry heavily influenced by MTV, where bands were not only expected to create great tunes but also produce visually appealing music videos, U2 opted to craft an album with minimal singles and videos that did not adhere to popular expectations. The Brian Eno-produced album was characterized by its stark, layered, and moody tones, creating sonic landscapes that were innovative and forward-thinking. This marked a departure from their previous post-punk sound and set the stage for the evolution of U2’s musical style.
Many at the time failed to grasp the significance of what U2 was trying to achieve, as they were consumed by the conventional expectations placed on bands. Instead of conforming to the norm of creating radio-friendly hits, U2 remained true to their artistic vision and authenticity. The band’s refusal to produce music solely for commercial success was a testament to their commitment to musical integrity and innovation.
While the exact placement of The Unforgettable Fire on BBC Music’s list may not be as crucial as its inclusion, it is undeniable that the album deserved a spot among the top releases of 1984. Alongside other exceptional choices like XTC’s The Big Express, David Sylvian’s Brilliant Trees, and the Smiths’ self-titled debut, U2’s fourth album should have been recognized for its artistry and impact.